City · New York · September 2026 data
Rent and Home Values in Sleepy Hollow, NY
In September 2026 Zillow data, typical rent in Sleepy Hollow, NY is $4,375 a month and a typical home is worth $1,052,686.
That is a price-to-rent ratio of 20.1: a typical home costs about 20.1 times a year of typical rent.
Over the past 12 months typical rent is up 8.0% and typical home value is up 10.5%.
- Typical home value
- $1,052,686
- Zillow ZHVI
- Typical rent
- $4,375/mo
- Zillow ZORI
- Price-to-rent ratio
- 20.1x
- value ÷ 12 months of rent
- Gross rent yield
- 5.0%
- annual rent ÷ value
- Rent, 12 months
- +8.0%
- vs Sep 2025
- Home value, 12 months
- +10.5%
- vs Sep 2025
How it compares
Among the 126 cities in New York with data, Sleepy Hollow, NY ranks 97th on price-to-rent ratio (20.1). Rank 1 is the lowest ratio.
The New York figure in the 4Homes state study is 12.3, which pairs the state's typical home value with typical rent in its largest metro, New York, NY. Sleepy Hollow, NY is 7.7 points above that figure.
Sleepy Hollow is part of the New York, NY metro area. Typical rent here is $4,375, 23% above the metro's $3,546; typical home value is $1,052,686, 44% above the metro's $730,949; the price-to-rent ratio is 20.1 against 17.2 for the metro.
Change over time
| Month | Typical home value | Typical rent | Price-to-rent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 2023 | $972,013 | $3,402/mo | 23.8x |
| Sep 2024 | $956,022 | $3,712/mo | 21.5x |
| Sep 2025 | $952,957 | $4,052/mo | 19.6x |
| Sep 2026 | $1,052,686 | $4,375/mo | 20.1x |
Other cities in the New York, NY metro area
- Dobbs Ferry, NY $3,629/mo, 23.9x
- Pompton Lakes, NJ $2,100/mo, 22.1x
- Southampton, NY $35,296/mo, 5.3x
- East Hanover Township, NJ $3,363/mo, 21.2x
- East Rutherford, NJ $2,828/mo, 19.0x
- Valley Cottage, NY $2,467/mo, 22.0x
- Wood Ridge, NJ $2,788/mo, 21.2x
- Elmsford, NY $3,215/mo, 18.4x
Frequently asked questions
What is the typical rent in Sleepy Hollow, NY?
Typical rent in Sleepy Hollow, NY is $4,375 a month in September 2026 data. This is Zillow's Observed Rent Index (ZORI), a smoothed, seasonally adjusted measure of typical market rent for single-family homes, condos and multi-family units. It describes the area, not any one listing.
What is the typical home value in Sleepy Hollow, NY?
The typical home value in Sleepy Hollow, NY is $1,052,686 in September 2026 data. This is Zillow's Home Value Index (ZHVI) for single-family homes and condos in the middle price tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted. It is not an appraisal or a price for a specific home.
What is the price-to-rent ratio in Sleepy Hollow, NY?
The price-to-rent ratio in Sleepy Hollow, NY is 20.1 in September 2026 data. It is the typical home value divided by 12 months of typical rent, so a typical home costs about 20.1 times a year of typical rent. A lower ratio means a year of rent is a larger share of the price; a higher ratio means a home costs more years of rent. Gross rent yield, annual rent divided by home value, is 5.0%. Both figures leave out taxes, insurance, repairs and vacancy, and neither is a quote or advice about a specific property.
Is rent rising in Sleepy Hollow, NY?
Typical rent in Sleepy Hollow, NY is up 8.0% from a year earlier, from $4,052 a month in Sep 2025 to $4,375 in Sep 2026. Typical home value is up 10.5% over the same 12 months. This is one 12-month comparison of Zillow's smoothed data. It describes the past and does not predict what rent will do next.
How does Sleepy Hollow, NY compare with New York?
Among the 126 cities in New York with data, Sleepy Hollow, NY ranks 97th on price-to-rent ratio (20.1), where 1st is the lowest ratio. The New York figure in the 4Homes state study is 12.3, which pairs the state's typical home value with typical rent in its largest metro, New York, NY. Within the New York, NY metro area, whose ratio is 17.2, Sleepy Hollow is higher.
Source and method
- Typical home value is Zillow's Home Value Index (ZHVI): the typical value of single-family homes and condos in the middle price tier (the 33rd to 67th percentile), smoothed and seasonally adjusted. Data month: September 2026.
- Typical rent is Zillow's Observed Rent Index (ZORI): the typical observed market rent across single-family homes, condos and multi-family units, smoothed and seasonally adjusted. Data month: September 2026.
- The two indexes do not cover exactly the same housing: rent includes multi-family units, home value covers single-family homes and condos.
- Price-to-rent ratio is typical home value divided by 12 months of typical rent. Gross rent yield is 12 months of typical rent divided by typical home value. Neither needs any loan terms, so both stay the same whatever lenders are charging.
- Changes compare the same calendar month in earlier years. Where an earlier figure is missing it is left out, not estimated.
- Ranks put the lowest price-to-rent ratio at 1st, the same as the 4Homes state study.
Source data: Zillow Research (zillow.com/research/data).
This is a screen, not a quote or advice. Typical figures for an area do not describe a specific property, and real deals depend on the property, its rent, its costs and its condition.